Despite the creepiness of the house, the girls decide to make the best of it by having showers and dressing up in skimpy lingerie. As four of the girls sleep, Janey is attacked by someone in a black hood, who slashes her offscreen with a hook. When Suzanne goes downstairs, she can't seem to find Janey, prompting the girls to looks everywhere around the house. Soon, Suzanne is killed by the unseen killer as well.

When the three remaining girls go down to the basement to look for the girls, they find their dead bodies in a moment of sheer terror. Armed with knives, they run out of the house and into the rain, but stop when they see Orville Ketchum standing across the street, who they immediately think is the killer. When the girls go back into the house, they start to panic when they encounter even freakier incidents. Has someone broken into their new sorority house? Or has the spirit of Clive Hockstatter returned?